Ivy Smoak Book Club

Who was devastated when Penny woke up and didn’t remember James?
If you woke up and didn’t remember being married to a handsome billionaire, would you push him away? Or jump right into that awesome new life?
Was your heart breaking for James as he tried to help Penny remember their past?
Do you think James should have just given Penny the book she wrote in the first place? Or did you love that he tried to recreate their past for her?
Did you want to reach into the book and shake Penny when she ran away from her life in New York?
Penny has vivid dreams of James, but she tries to convince herself that they aren’t memories. Did that make you want to shake her again?
Did you laugh when Penny thought Brendan was Tyler?
Did you have fun revisiting some of the places where James and Penny first fell in love?
Penny instantly feels connected to Liam even though she doesn’t remember having him. Do you think maybe a part of her feels close to him because he looks so much like James?
Scarlett treats her mother like an imposter. If you have children, how hurtful would it be if they pretended you were an imposter?
Show of hands…who laughed out loud when Scarlett had that “accident” at the zoo?
Penny is finally remembering James. But freaking Dr. Nelson prevents her from getting the chance to tell him. Do you think Penny will get a chance? Or is Dr. Nelson really going to be the end of James and Penny?

Keep the Discussion Going

Join my facebook reader group and come hang out with over 18,000 other Ivy fans!