Ivy Smoak Book Club

Surprise! James and Penny are already having their second kid! Did you expect the time jump?
Scarlett is a total Daddy’s girl. If you have kids, do you worry that they have a clear favorite parent? And if so, does it mess with your head?
It’s important for Penny to have her writing be her own thing. Is there a hobby or passion (other than this awesome book club) that you do just for you?
Would you have skipped your best friend’s wedding if you were supposed to be on bed rest?
I know James and Penny are already a thing, but was anyone kind of feeling #TeamMatt?
And how badly do you want Scarlett and Axel to be a thing in the future?!
James went behind Penny’s back to get her a publishing deal, even though she told him she didn’t want it. Was he in the wrong, or is it actually a really sweet surprise?
James wasn’t there when Penny needed him. If she wakes up, do you think she’ll be able to forgive him?
Do you think James is strong enough to raise two kids on his own?
Given all the evidence, if you were James, would you believe that Penny tried to kill herself?
Scarlett did try to warn her parents throughout the whole book. Did you think she was actually trying to get something across, or would you have dismissed the Snape warnings too?
We thought once Isabella was out of the picture, everything would be smooth sailing. Who expected Dr. Nelson?
Do you think either James or Penny survive this?

Keep the Discussion Going

Join my facebook reader group and come hang out with over 18,000 other Ivy fans!